June 13, 1877 at Evansville
Evansville 2, Cincinnati 9GameID g06131877-07
| 1b | Conley |
| 3b | Harry McCaffrey |
| c | Sleeper Sullivan |
| p | Dean Simpson |
| 2b | John Boro |
| cf | Ed Kelly |
| ss | H Lloyd |
| lf | Ed McNeeley |
| rf | John Dyler |
| cf | Jimmy Hallinan |
| 2b | Lip Pike |
| p | Jack Manning |
| lf | Bob Addy |
| ss | Amos Booth |
| 1b | Charlie Gould |
| 3b | Will Foley |
| c | Henry Kessler |
| rf | Bobby Mathews |
