April 23, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 6, Indianapolis 4GameID g04231877-06
| rf | Bob Addy |
| cf | Lip Pike |
| 1b | Charley Jones |
| 2b | Jimmy Hallinan |
| lf | Ned Cuthbert |
| 3b | Will Foley |
| c | Nat Hicks |
| ss | Amos Booth |
| p | Bobby Mitchell |
| 2b | Joe Quest |
| cf | Trick McSorley |
| ss | Denny Mack |
| 1b | Charles Houtz |
| lf | Mike Golden |
| c | Silver Flint |
| 3b | Fred Warner |
| rf | Adam Rocap |
| p | Ed Nolan |
