| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 19 | Brent Butler | 1996 | Best Appalachian League All-Stars | |
| NNO (4) | Brent Butler | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| 409 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman | Scan |
| 409 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman International | Scan |
| 271 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman Chrome | Scan |
| 271 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman Chrome Refractors | Scan |
| 271 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman Chrome International | Scan |
| 271 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Bowman Chrome International Refractors | Scan |
| 93 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Best | |
| 1 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 18 | Brent Butler | 1997 | Best Midwest League Top Prospects | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman - Golden Anniversary | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman - International | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome - Golden Anniversary | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome - Golden Anniversary Refractors | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome - International | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome - International Refractors | |
| 154 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman Chrome - Refractors | |
| 142 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman's Best | |
| 142 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman's Best - Atomic Refractors | |
| 142 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Bowman's Best - Refractors | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps - Inaugural Devil Rays | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps - Inaugural Diamondbacks | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps - Minted in Cooperstown | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps Chrome | |
| 260 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Topps Chrome - Refractors | |
| 2 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Blueline Q-Cards Carolina League Top Prospects | |
| 17 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Blueline Q-Cards Prince William Cannons | |
| 14 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Choice Carolina League All-Stars | |
| 105 | Brent Butler | 1998 | SP Top Prospects | |
| BB | Brent Butler | 1998 | SP Top Prospects - Autographs | |
| D7 | Brent Butler | 1998 | SP Top Prospects - Destination The Show | |
| D7 | Brent Butler | 1998 | SP Top Prospects - Destination The Show President's Edition | |
| 105 | Brent Butler | 1998 | SP Top Prospects - President's Edition | |
| 7 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Team Best | |
| 59 | Brent Butler | 1998 | Team Best | |
| NNO (6) | Brent Butler | 1998 | Team Best - Autographs Signature Series | |
| 217 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Bowman | |
| 217 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 212 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Topps | Scan |
| 212 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Topps Chrome | |
| 24 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Upper Deck SP Top Prospects | |
| 24 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Upper Deck SP Top Prospects President's Edition | |
| BB | Brent Butler | 1999 | Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Chirography | |
| GF06 | Brent Butler | 1999 | Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Great Futures | |
| 40 | Brent Butler | 2000 | SP Top Prospects | |
| 40 | Brent Butler | 2000 | SP Top Prospects Premium Edition | |
| 40 | Brent Butler | 2000 | SP Top Prospects President's Edition |
