| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 32 | Chris Carpenter | 2003 | Topps Traded & Rookies | Scan |
| 462 | Chris Carpenter | 2003 | Upper Deck 40 Man | |
| 462 | Chris Carpenter | 2003 | Upper Deck 40 Man Rainbow Parallel | |
| 143 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Bazooka | |
| 315 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Bowman Heritage | |
| 220 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Cracker Jack | |
| 217 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Donruss Diamond Kings | |
| 217 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Donruss Diamond Kings Challenge | |
| 219 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Donruss Throwback Threads | |
| 164 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Donruss Zenith | |
| 64 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Leaf Limited | |
| 305 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 52 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 207 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps | Scan |
| 727 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps | Scan |
| 144 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 146 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 170 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 194 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 89 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Bazooka | |
| 44 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Bowman | |
| 44 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 103 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Bowman Heritage | |
| CC | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Bowman Sterling | |
| 91 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | eTopps | |
| 107 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Finest | |
| 19 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Flair Showcase | |
| 83 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Fleer | |
| 51 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Fleer Tradition | |
| 184 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | SP Authentic | |
| 86 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | SPx | |
| 261 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps | Scan |
| 488 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps | Scan |
| 199 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 215 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 260 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 296 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 322 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Updates & Highlights | Scan |
| 211 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 183 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Chrome | |
| 271 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Chrome | |
| 78 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Co-Signers | |
| 158 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Heritage | |
| 27 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 344 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Turkey Red | |
| STL2 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Topps Team Sets | |
| 39 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Ultra | |
| 420 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck | |
| 83 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Artifacts | |
| 230 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Epic | |
| 179 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck First Pitch | |
| 65 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Future Stars | |
| 20 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Ovation | |
| 420 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Special F/X | |
| 122 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot | |
| 86 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot Update | |
| 86 | Chris Carpenter | 2006 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection | |
| 124 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Bowman | |
| 124 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 62 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Bowman Heritage | |
| 100 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Finest | |
| 42 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Fleer | |
| 47 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | SP Authentic | |
| 47 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | SP Rookie Edition | |
| 97 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | SPx | |
| 240 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps | Scan |
| 226 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 103 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Chrome | |
| 287 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Heritage | |
| 41 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Opening Day | |
| 91 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 72 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Turkey Red | |
| STL10 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Topps Team Sets | |
| 150 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Ultra | |
| 451 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck | |
| 964 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck | |
| 965 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck | |
| 68 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Artifacts | |
| 21 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Rookie Signatures | |
| 88 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Future Stars | |
| 133 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Goudey | |
| 76 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Premier | |
| 97 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Spectrum | |
| 24 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot | |
| 47 | Chris Carpenter | 2007 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection | |
| 63 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Bowman | |
| 60 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 63 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Finest | |
| 88 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | SPx | |
| 630 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps | Scan |
| 287 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 165 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps Chrome | |
| 345 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps Heritage | |
| 151 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps Opening Day | |
| STL10 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Topps Team Sets | |
| 651 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck | |
| 89 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck A Piece of History | |
| 89 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 322 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 158 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Baseball Heroes | |
| 470 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck First Edition | |
| 85 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Masterpieces | |
| 89 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Spectrum | |
| 27 | Chris Carpenter | 2008 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot | |
| 66 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps eTopps | |
| 484 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps | Scan |
| STL2 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | Scan |
| 239 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 67 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 38 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Topps Unique | |
| 345 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck | |
| 87 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck A Piece of History | |
| 122 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 274 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 292 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 320 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 343 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Ballpark Collection | |
| 266 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck First Edition | |
| 27 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Signature Stars | |
| 20 | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot | |
| 45 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Bowman | |
| 15 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 73 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps | Scan |
| 106 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps | Scan |
| 479a | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps | Scan |
| 86 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps 206 | |
| 182 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 33 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Attax | |
| 99 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Chrome | |
| 32 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Heritage | |
| 45 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Heritage | |
| 47 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Heritage | |
| 135 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps National Chicle | |
| 153 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Opening Day | |
| 106 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| STL11 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Topps Team Sets | |
| 474 | Chris Carpenter | 2010 | Upper Deck | |
| 96 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Bowman | Scan |
| 82 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 50 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Playoff Contenders | |
| 299 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps | Scan |
| 295 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 51 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Attax | |
| 121 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Chrome | |
| 16 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 83 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 38 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Lineage | |
| 131 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps Opening Day | |
| WS14 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps World Series Champions Cardinals | |
| STL2 | Chris Carpenter | 2011 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 157 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Bowman | Scan |
| 169 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Bowman Chrome | |
| STL-6 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | SP Signature Edition | |
| 92 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps | Scan |
| 264 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps | Scan |
| 490 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps | Scan |
| 112 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 134 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Archives | Scan |
| 17 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Chrome | |
| 138 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 415a | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 415b | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 415c | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 96 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Opening Day | Scan |
| 253 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps Stickers | |
| STL6 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 631 | Chris Carpenter | 2013 | Topps | Scan |
| 75 | Chris Carpenter | 2013 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 190 | Chris Carpenter | 2013 | Topps Opening Day | Scan |
| 223 | Chris Carpenter | 2013 | Topps Stickers | |
| STL4 | Chris Carpenter | 2013 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 195 | Chris Carpenter | 2014 | Topps Allen & Ginter |
