| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 10 | Jon Jay | 2006 | Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Draft Picks | |
| 10 | Jon Jay | 2006 | Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects Draft Picks | |
| 89 | Jon Jay | 2008 | Playoff Contenders | |
| 15 | Jon Jay | 2008 | Grandstand Springfield Cardinals | |
| 15 | Jon Jay | 2009 | Multi-Ad Memphis Redbirds | Scan |
| 202 | Jon Jay | 2010 | Bowman Chrome | |
| BDP18 | Jon Jay | 2010 | Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects | |
| 46 | Jon Jay | 2010 | Bowman Sterling | |
| US-203a | Jon Jay | 2010 | Topps Update | Scan |
| 178 | Jon Jay | 2010 | Topps Chrome | |
| 11 | Jon Jay | 2010 | Multi-Ad Memphis Redbirds | Scan |
| 295 | Jon Jay | 2011 | Topps | Scan |
| 323 | Jon Jay | 2011 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| WS6 | Jon Jay | 2011 | Topps World Series Champions Cardinals | |
| STL8 | Jon Jay | 2011 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 258 | Jon Jay | 2012 | Topps | Scan |
| 250 | Jon Jay | 2012 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| STL2 | Jon Jay | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 54 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Bowman | Scan |
| 148 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Bowman Chrome | |
| 224 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps | Scan |
| 172 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps Allen & Ginter | |
| 7 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps Archives | Scan |
| 4 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps Chrome | |
| 69 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 244 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| STL14 | Jon Jay | 2013 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 538 | Jon Jay | 2014 | Topps | Scan |
| 56 | Jon Jay | 2014 | Topps Archives | |
| 120 | Jon Jay | 2014 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 21 | Jon Jay | 2014 | Topps Heritage |
