| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 22 | Mike Matheny | 2000 | Cardinals Police Safety Set | |
| 203 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Bowman Heritage | |
| 408 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | MLB Showdown | |
| 354 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Pacific | |
| 74 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Topps | Scan |
| 74 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Topps Limited | |
| 56 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Topps Chrome | |
| 53 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Upper Deck Gold Glove | |
| 53 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Upper Deck Gold Glove Limited | |
| 53 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Upper Deck Gold Glovee Finite | |
| 190 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Upper Deck MVP | |
| 321 | Mike Matheny | 2001 | Upper Deck Victory | |
| 313 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | MLB Showdown | |
| 4 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Topps | Scan |
| 4 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Topps Chrome | |
| 72 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Topps Heritage | |
| 32 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Topps Opening Day | |
| 166 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Topps Total | |
| 575 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Upper Deck 40 Man | |
| 291 | Mike Matheny | 2002 | Upper Deck Victory | |
| 45 | Mike Matheny | 2003 | MLB Showdown Pennant Run | |
| 89 | Mike Matheny | 2003 | Topps | Scan |
| 405 | Mike Matheny | 2003 | Upper Deck | |
| 446 | Mike Matheny | 2003 | Upper Deck 40 Man | |
| 446 | Mike Matheny | 2003 | Upper Deck 40 Man Rainbow Parallel | |
| 345 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | Donruss | |
| 398 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | Donruss Team Heroes | |
| 147 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | Fleer Tradition | |
| 312 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | MLB Showdown | |
| 6 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | Topps | Scan |
| 706 | Mike Matheny | 2004 | Topps | Scan |
| 340 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | Donruss | |
| 57 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | Fleer Tradition | |
| 309 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 124 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | Topps | Scan |
| 705 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | Topps | Scan |
| 413 | Mike Matheny | 2013 | Topps Heritage | Scan |
| 126 | Mike Matheny | 2014 | Topps Heritage |