| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 167 | Tim McCarver | 1962 | Topps | Scan |
| 394 | Tim McCarver | 1963 | Topps | Scan |
| 429 | Tim McCarver | 1964 | Topps | Scan |
| 294 | Tim McCarver | 1965 | Topps | Scan |
| 275 | Tim McCarver | 1966 | Topps | Scan |
| 485 | Tim McCarver | 1967 | Topps | Scan |
| 275 | Tim McCarver | 1968 | Topps | Scan |
| 376 | Tim McCarver | 1968 | Topps | Scan |
| 35 | Tim McCarver | 1968 | Bazooka | Scan |
| 475 | Tim McCarver | 1969 | Topps | Scan |
| 34 | Tim McCarver | 1970 | Kellogg's | Scan |
| 23 | Tim McCarver | 1970 | Topps Super | Scan |
| 269 | Tim McCarver | 1973 | O-Pee-Chee | |
| 269 | Tim McCarver | 1973 | Topps | Scan |
| 520 | Tim McCarver | 1974 | O-Pee-Chee | |
| 520 | Tim McCarver | 1974 | Topps | Scan |
| 386 | Tim McCarver | 1981 | TCMA The 60s (Series 2) | Scan |
| 10 | Tim McCarver | 1983 | TCMA Cardinals Greats | Scan |
| 36 | Tim McCarver | 1992 | Pacific McDonald's St. Louis Cardinals | Scan |
| 81 | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| BBRR-TMC | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Topps American Pie Rookie Reprint Relics | |
| 40 | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Topps Archives | |
| 54 | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Upper Deck 1970's Decade | |
| 106 | Tim McCarver | 2002 | Topps Archives | |
| 80 | Tim McCarver | 2002 | Topps Super Teams 1967 | |
| 79 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Greats of the Game | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Bronze | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Bronze | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Gold | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Gold | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Legendary Signatures | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Legendary Signatures | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Gold Sigantures | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Gold Sigantures | |
| 4 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Platinum Sigantures | |
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Platinum Sigantures | |
| GM | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Legendary Combo Dual Signatures | |
| GBM | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Legendary Combo Triple Signatures | |
| TT-SC | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Timeless Team Logos | |
| TT-SC | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Hat Logos | |
| TT-SC | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams League Logos | |
| TT-SC | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Stats | |
| TT-SC | Tim McCarver | 2004 | Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams Team Logos | |
| 90 | Tim McCarver | 2006 | Fleer Greats of the Game |
