| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 334 | Tim Sherrill | 1988 | ProCards Savannah Cardinals | Scan |
| 24 | Tim Sherrill | 1989 | Star St. Petersburg Cardinals | Scan |
| 24 | Tim Sherrill | 1989 | Star Glossy St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 63 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | Topps TV St. Louis Cardinals | Scan |
| 122 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | CMC | Scan |
| 22 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | CMC Louisville Redbirds | Scan |
| 37 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | Louisville Redbirds Team Set | Scan |
| 403 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | ProCards Louisville Redbirds | Scan |
| 517 | Tim Sherrill | 1990 | ProCards AAA | Scan |
| 769 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 769 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Topps | Scan |
| 769 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Topps Desert Shield | Scan |
| 769 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Topps Tiffany | |
| 142 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Topps Debut '90 | Scan |
| 6 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Louisville Redbirds Team Set | Scan |
| 247 | Tim Sherrill | 1991 | Line Drive AAA | Scan |
| 404 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Score | Scan |
| 90 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Score 100 Rising Stars | Scan |
| 822 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Stadium Club | Scan |
| 822 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Stadium Club East Coast National | |
| 17 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Louisville Redbirds Team Set | |
| 1887 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Fleer/ProCards Louisville Redbirds | Scan |
| 269 | Tim Sherrill | 1992 | Skybox Louisville Redbirds | Scan |