| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 166 | George Sisler | 1916 | M101-5 Sporting News | Scan |
| 164 | George Sisler | 1916 | M101-4 Sporting News | Scan |
| 162 | George Sisler | 1917 | E135 Collins-McCarthy | Scan |
| 98 | George Sisler | 1921 | American Caramel E121 Series of 80 | Scan |
| 99 | George Sisler | 1921 | American Caramel E121 Series of 80 | Scan |
| 97 | George Sisler | 1922 | American Caramel E121 Series of 120 | Scan |
| 97B | George Sisler | 1922 | American Caramel E121 Series of 120 | Scan |
| 202 | George Sisler | 1922 | American Caramel E120 Series of 240 | Scan |
| 66 | George Sisler | 1922 | American Caramel E122 Series of 80 | Scan |
| 67 | George Sisler | 1922 | American Caramel E122 Series of 80 | Scan |
| 97 | George Sisler | 1922 | National Caramel E220 | Scan |
| 49 | George Sisler | 1927 | American Caramel E126 Series of 60 | Scan |
| 179 | George Sisler | 1940 | Playball (R335) | Scan |
| 5 | George Sisler | 1972 | Kellogg's All-Time Greats | Scan |
| 411 | George Sisler | 1979 | Topps | Scan |
| 94 | George Sisler | 1980 | TCMA Renata-Galasso (Series III) | Scan |
| 83 | George Sisler | 1981 | Sporting News Conlon Collection | Scan |
| 22 | George Sisler | 1982 | TCMA Greatest Hitters | Scan |
| 33 | George Sisler | 1985 | Woolworth All-Time Record Holders | Scan |
| 58 | George Sisler | 1987 | Conlon World Wide Sports (Series 2) | Scan |
| 25 | George Sisler | 1988 | Baseball Immortals (1980-1988) | Scan |
| 26 | George Sisler | 1988 | Conlon World Wide Sports (Series 4) | Scan |
| 66 | George Sisler | 1991 | Conlon Collection TSN | Scan |
| 798 | George Sisler | 1993 | Conlon Collection TSN | Scan |
| 104 | George Sisler | 1995 | Cooperstown Plaque Postcards | |
| 33 | George Sisler | 1999 | Upper Deck Century Legends | |
| 33 | George Sisler | 1999 | Upper Deck Century Legends Century Collection | |
| 10 | George Sisler | 2001 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| GS-BT | George Sisler | 2001 | SP Legendary Cuts Combo Bat Cards | |
| D-GS | George Sisler | 2001 | SP Legendary Cuts Debut Bat Cards | |
| C-GSi | George Sisler | 2001 | SP Legendary Cuts Autograph Cards | |
| 45 | George Sisler | 2002 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classics | |
| GS | George Sisler | 2004 | SP Legendary Cuts Legendary Cuts | |
| 185 | George Sisler | 2006 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 47 | George Sisler | 2006 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection | |
| 86 | George Sisler | 2007 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 189 | George Sisler | 2007 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 19 | George Sisler | 2007 | Upper Deck Premier | |
| 187 | George Sisler | 2007 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic | |
| 225 | George Sisler | 2008 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 115b | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps | Scan |
| 300a | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps 206 | |
| 300b | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps 206 | |
| 48 | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps Sterling | |
| 16 | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps Tribute | |
| 24 | George Sisler | 2009 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 125b | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps | Scan |
| 402 | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps Heritage | |
| 236 | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps National Chicle | |
| 286 | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps National Chicle | |
| 120 | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps Sterling | |
| 99 | George Sisler | 2010 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 81 | George Sisler | 2011 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 40 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 95 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Gypsy Queen | |
| 27 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Lineage | |
| 18 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Marquee | |
| 60 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Tribute | |
| 69 | George Sisler | 2011 | Topps Triple Threads | |
| 54 | George Sisler | 2014 | Panini Classics |
