| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 10 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | Coca-Cola/Topps | Scan |
| 560 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | Donruss | Scan |
| 56 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | Kellogg's | Scan |
| 9 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 838 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | Topps Traded | Scan |
| 221 | Bruce Sutter | 1981 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 372 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Donruss | Scan |
| 129 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Fleer | Scan |
| 631 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Fleer | Scan |
| 17 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Kellogg's | Scan |
| 260 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 347 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 15 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | O-Pee-Chee Stickers | Scan |
| 94 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | O-Pee-Chee Stickers | Scan |
| 130 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | O-Pee-Chee Stickers | Scan |
| 22 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Squirt | Scan |
| 168 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps | Scan |
| 260 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps | Scan |
| 347 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps | Scan |
| 15 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 94 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 130 | Bruce Sutter | 1982 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 40 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Donruss | Scan |
| 41 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Donruss Action All-Stars | Scan |
| 24 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Fleer | Scan |
| 1 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Fleer Star Stickers | Scan |
| 37 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Kellogg's | Scan |
| 150 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 151 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 266 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 150 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps | Scan |
| 151 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps | Scan |
| 407 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps | Scan |
| 708 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps | Scan |
| 40 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps All-Star Glossy | Scan |
| 166 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 187 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 209 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 284 | Bruce Sutter | 1983 | Topps Stickers | Scan |
| 13 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Donruss | Scan |
| 534 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Donruss | Scan |
| 338 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Fleer | Scan |
| 70 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Fleer Star Stickers | Scan |
| 709 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Nestle | Scan |
| 730 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Nestle | Scan |
| 243 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 24 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Ralston Purina | Scan |
| 709 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Topps | Scan |
| 730 | Bruce Sutter | 1984 | Topps | Scan |
| 109 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Donruss | Scan |
| 44 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Drakes Big Hitters and Super Pitchers | Scan |
| 241 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Fleer | Scan |
| 163 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Leaf Donruss | Scan |
| 370 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | O-Pee-Chee | Scan |
| 9 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Topps | Scan |
| 370 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Topps | Scan |
| 722 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Topps | Scan |
| 22 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Topps All-Stars Glossy (40 cards) | Scan |
| 9 | Bruce Sutter | 1985 | Topps Supers | Scan |
| 52 | Bruce Sutter | 1992 | Pacific McDonald's St. Louis Cardinals | Scan |
| DJS-SG | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Dual Materials Signature | |
| DS-SG | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Dual | |
| SS-STL | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Six | |
| SU | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Tier B | |
| TS-SGG | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Triple | |
| SU | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Tier B 1 of 1 Parallel | |
| SU | Bruce Sutter | 2004 | Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Tier B Parallel | |
| 144 | Bruce Sutter | 2006 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 78 | Bruce Sutter | 2007 | Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic | |
| 11 | Bruce Sutter | 2008 | Donruss Prime Cuts | |
| 199 | Bruce Sutter | 2008 | SP Legendary Cuts | |
| 2 | Bruce Sutter | 2014 | Topps Archives | |
| 76 | Bruce Sutter | 2014 | Topps Gypsy Queen |