| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| NNO (1) | Tom Dolan | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (2a) | Tip O'Neill | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (2b) | Tip O'Neill | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (2c) | Tip O'Neill | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (2d) | Tip O'Neill | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (3) | Harry Lyons | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (4) | Jim Devlin | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (5a) | Yank Robinson | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (5b) | Yank Robinson | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (5c) | Yank Robinson | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (6a) | Jocko Milligan | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (6b) | Jocko Milligan | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (7a) | John Boyle | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (7b) | John Boyle | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (8) | Pete Somers | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (9) | Fred Knouff | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (10) | Silver King | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (11) | Nat Hudson | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (12a) | Charlie Comiskey | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (12b) | Charlie Comiskey | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (13a) | Tommy McCarthy | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (13b) | Tommy McCarthy | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (14) | Arlie Latham | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (15) | Chippy McGarr | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (16) | John Crooks | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (17) | Harry Staley | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (18) | Charles Alcott | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (19) | J.J. Kenyon | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (20-neg) | Tug Arundel | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (20-pos) | Tug Arundel | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (21) | Joseph Herr | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (22) | Bart Cantz | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (23) | Ernest Burch | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (24) | Hunkey Hines | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (25) | Tom Loftus | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (26) | Jake Beckley | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (27) | Frederick Nyce | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (28) | John McCormack | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (29) | Ed Sproat | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (30) | Tom Nicholson | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (31) | Charlie Duffee | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (32a) | Shorty Fuller | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (32b) | Shorty Fuller | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (32c) | Shorty Fuller | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (33a) | Elton Chamberlain | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (33b) | Elton Chamberlain | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (33c) | Elton Chamberlain | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
