| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 1 | Juan Agosto | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 2 | Cris Carpenter | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 3 | Jose DeLeon | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 4 | Frank Dipino | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 5 | Rich Gedman | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 6 | Bernard Gilkey | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 7 | Pedro Guerrero | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 8 | Ken Hill | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 9 | Rex Hudler | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 10 | Felix Jose | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 11 | Ray Lankford | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 12 | Joe Magrane | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 13 | Omar Olivares | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 14 | Jose Oquendo | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 15 | Tom Pagnozzi | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 16 | Geronimo Pena | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 17 | Gerald Perry | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 18 | Bryn Smith | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 19 | Lee Smith | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 20 | Ozzie Smith | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 21 | Bob Tewksbury | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 22 | Milt Thompson | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 23 | Joe Torre | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 24 | Craig Wilson | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 25 | Todd Worrell | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 26 | Todd Zeile | 1991 | Smokey Bear St. Louis Cardinals |