| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 1 | Greg Almond | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 2 | Charlie Anderson | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 3 | Chance Cain | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 4 | David Carroll | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 5 | Hector Colon | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 6 | Keith Conway | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 7 | Rich Croushore | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 8 | Dee Dalton | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 9 | Ray Davis | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 10 | Darren Doucette | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 11 | Aaron Gerteisen | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 12 | Keith Jones | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 13 | Dave Madsen | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 14 | Andy Martin | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 15 | Jeff Matulevich | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 16 | Joe McEwing | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 17 | Jeremy McGarity | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 18 | Santo Mota | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 19 | Marc Ottmers | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 20 | Jamie Sailors | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 21 | Steve Santucci | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 22 | Duane Stanton | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 23 | Jesus Ugueto | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 24 | Joe Wallace | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 25 | Mike Windham | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 26 | Jay Witasick | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 27 | Joe Cunningham III | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 28 | Ray Searage | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 29 | Steve Proctor | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters | |
| 30 | Checklist | 1994 | Classic Best Madison Hatters |