| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 10 | Tony La Russa | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 41 | Alan Benes | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 40 | Andy Benes | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 38 | Pat Borders | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 12 | Royce Clayton | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 43 | Dennis Eckersley | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 48 | Tony Fossas | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 8 | Gary Gaetti | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 22 | Mike Gallego | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 5 | Ron Gant | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 32 | Rick Honeycutt | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 29 | Danny Jackson | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 3 | Brian Jordan | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 16 | Ray Lankford | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 47 | John Mabry | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 33 | T.J. Mathews | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 51 | Willie McGee | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 36 | Mike Morgan | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 31 | Donovan Osborne | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 19 | Tom Pagnozzi | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 46 | Mark Petkovsek | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 1 | Ozzie Smith | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 30 | Todd Stottlemyre | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 23 | Mark Sweeney | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| 24 | Tom Urbani | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police | |
| NNO | Fredbird Mascot | 1996 | St. Louis Cardinals Police |