| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 1 | Scott Melvin | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 2 | Darrell Betts | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 3 | Bryan Britt | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 4 | Ken Cameron | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 5 | Bryan Clark | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 6 | Kevin Crafton | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 7 | Lou Deman | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 8 | Tony Falciglia | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 9 | Keith Finnerty | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 10 | Joe Freitas | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 11 | Keith Gallagher | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 12 | Andrew Gordon | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 13 | Greg Heffernan | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 14 | Ruben Jimenez | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 15 | Brad Kennedy | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 16 | Stacy Kleiner | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 17 | Jeff Love | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 18 | Brian Mazurek | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 19 | Mike McDougal | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 20 | Mark Nussbeck | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 21 | Jason Pollock | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 22 | Jay Reames | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 23 | Jorge Roque | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 24 | Dave Schmidt | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 25 | Andy Schofield | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 26 | Gene Stechschulte | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 27 | Hector Ugueto | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 28 | Jon Ward | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 29 | Adam West | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 30 | Paul Wilders | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals |