| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 7 | Bob Gibson | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 17 | Curt Flood | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 51 | Keith Hernandez | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 53 | Lou Brock | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 65 | Ozzie Smith | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 81 | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| 95 | Stan Musial | 2001 | Topps American Pie | |
| BPA2 | Bob Gibson | 2001 | Topps American Pie Autoproofs Baseball Legends | |
| DL8 | Bob Gibson | 2001 | Topps American Pie Decade Leaders | |
| TT18R | Bob Gibson | 2001 | Topps American Pie Legends Autographs | |
| PIC2 | Lou Brock | 2001 | Topps American Pie Profiles In Courage | |
| BBRR-SC | Steve Carlton | 2001 | Topps American Pie Rookie Reprint Relics | |
| BBRR-TMC | Tim McCarver | 2001 | Topps American Pie Rookie Reprint Relics | |
| BBTC-44 | Keith Hernandez | 2001 | Topps American Pie Timeless Classics Relics | |
| BBWM-SM | Stan Musial | 2001 | Topps American Pie Woodstock Relics |