| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 305 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 306 | Jim Edmonds | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 307 | Jason Isringhausen | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 308 | Ray King | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 309 | Mike Matheny | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 310 | Matt Morris | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 311 | Albert Pujols | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 312 | Edgar Renteria | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 313 | Scott Rolen | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 314 | Reggie Sanders | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 315 | Julian Tavarez | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 316 | Larry Walker | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 317 | Woody Williams | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 318 | Tony Womack | 2005 | MLB Showdown | |
| 52 | Chris Carpenter | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 56 | Cal Eldred | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 69 | Al Reyes | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 101 | Mark Mulder | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 113 | Einar Diaz | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 114 | Mark Grudzielanek | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 115 | Jason Marquis | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 117 | John Mabry | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 128 | David Eckstein | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 144 | Jeff Suppan | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline | |
| 152 | Roger Cedeno | 2005 | MLB Showdown Trading Deadline |