| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 16 | Chris Perez | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 22 | Khalil Greene | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 40 | Ryan Ludwick | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 84 | Yadier Molina | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 124 | Jason Motte | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 195 | Ryan Franklin | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 220 | Tony LaRussa | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 242 | St. Louis Cardinals | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 250 | Albert Pujols | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 275 | Skip Schumaker | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 327 | Kyle Lohse | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 331 | Troy Glaus | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 355 | Rick Ankiel | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 368 | Aaron Miles | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 468 | Dave Duncan | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 468 | Hal McRae | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 468 | Jose Oquendo | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 468 | Dave McKay | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 501 | Shane Robinson | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 507 | John Smoltz | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 518 | Blake Hawksworth | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 555 | David Freese | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 584 | Julio Lugo | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 590 | Jarrett Hoffpauir | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 652 | Tyler Greene | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 694 | Colby Rasmus | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 708 | Mark DeRosa | 2009 | Topps Heritage | |
| 709 | Matt Holliday | 2009 | Topps Heritage |