| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| STL1 | David Freese | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL2 | Jon Jay | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL3 | Matt Holliday | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL4 | Carlos Beltran | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL5 | Yadier Molina | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL6 | Chris Carpenter | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL7 | Allen Craig | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL8 | Skip Schumaker | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL9 | Rafael Furcal | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL10 | Adam Wainwright | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL11 | Kyle Lohse | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL12 | Lance Berkman | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL13 | Daniel Descalso | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL14 | Jaime Garcia | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL15 | Jason Motte | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL16 | Fredbird | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals | |
| STL17 | Busch Stadium | 2012 | Topps St. Louis Cardinals |