Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Richie Ashburn	Phi-N
2	Hank Bauer	NY-A
3	Yogi Berra	NY-A
4	Ewell Blackwell	Cin-N
5	Bobby Brown	NY-A
6	Jim Busby	Was-A
7	Roy Campanella	Bro-N
8	Chico Carrasquel	Chi-A
9	Jerry Coleman	NY-A
10	Joe Collins	NY-A
11	Alvin Dark	NY-N
12	Dom DiMaggio	Bos-A
13	Joe DiMaggio	NY-A
14	Larry Doby	Cle-A
15	Bobby Doerr	Bos-A
16	Bob Elliott	Bos-N
17	Del Ennis	Phi-N
18	Ferris Fain	Phi-A
19	Bob Feller	Cle-A
20	Nellie Fox	Chi-A
21	Ned Garver	StL-A
22	Clint Hartung	NY-N
23	Jim Hearn	NY-N
24	Gil Hodges	Bro-N
25	Monte Irvin	NY-N
26	Larry Jansen	NY-N
27	Sheldon Jones	Bos-N
28	George Kell	Det-A
29	Monte Kennedy	NY-N
30	Ralph Kiner	Pit-N
31	Dave Koslo	NY-N
32	Bob Kuzava	NY-A
33	Bob Lemon	Cle-A
34	Whitey Lockman	NY-N
35	Ed Lopat	NY-A
36	Sal Maglie	NY-N
37	Mickey Mantle	NY-A
38	Billy Martin	NY-A
39	Willie Mays	NY-N
40	Gil McDougald	NY-A
41	Minnie Minoso	Chi-A
42	Johnny Mize	NY-A
43	Tom Morgan	NY-A
44	Don Mueller	NY-N
45	Stan Musial	StL-N
46	Don Newcombe	Bro-N
47	Ray Noble	NY-N
48	Joe Ostrowski	NY-A
49	Mel Parnell	Bos-A
50	Vic Raschi	NY-A
51	Pee Wee Reese	Bro-N
52	Allie Reynolds	NY-A
53	Bill Rigney	NY-N
54a	Phil Rizzuto	NY-A	Bunting
54b	Phil Rizzuto	NY-A	Swinging
55	Robin Roberts	Phi-N
56	Eddie Robinson	Chi-A
57	Jackie Robinson	Bro-N
58	Preacher Roe	Bro-N
59	Johnny Sain	NY-A
60	Red Schoendienst	StL-N
61	Duke Snider	Bro-N
62	George Spencer	NY-N
63	Eddie Stanky	NY-N	Line on back indicates trade to Cardinals
64	Hank Thompson	NY-N
65	Bobby Thomson	NY-N
66	Vic Wertz	Det-A
67	Wally Westlake	StL-N
68	Wes Westrum	NY-N
69	Ted Williams	Bos-A
70	Gene Woodling	NY-A
71	Gus Zernial	Phi-A