
There are 54 cards in the set
| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| 1A | Bobby Avila | Cle-A | |
| 1N | Richie Ashburn | Phi-N | |
| 2A | Jim Busby | Was-A | |
| 2N | Billy Cox | Bro-N | |
| 3A | Nelson Fox | Chi-A | |
| 3N | Del Crandall | Mil-N | |
| 4A | George Kell | Bos-A | Boston |
| 4A | George Kell | Chi-A | Chicago |
| 4N | Carl Erskine | Bro-N | |
| 5A | Sherman Lollar | Chi-A | |
| 5N | Monte Irvin | NY-N | |
| 6A | Sam Mele | Bal-A | Baltimore |
| 6A | Sam Mele | Chi-A | Chicago |
| 6N | Ted Kluszewski | Cin-N | |
| 7A | Minnie Minoso | Chi-A | |
| 7N | Don Mueller | NY-N | |
| 8A | Mel Parnell | Bos-A | |
| 8N | Andy Pafko | Mil-N | |
| 9A | Dave Philley | Cle-A | Cleveland |
| 9A | Dave Philley | Phi-A | Philadelphia |
| 9N | Del Rice | StL-N | |
| 10A | Billy Pierce | Chi-A | |
| 10N | Red Schoendienst | StL-N | |
| 11A | Jim Piersall | Bos-A | |
| 11N | Warren Spahn | Mil-N | |
| 12A | Al Rosen | Cle-A | |
| 12N | Curt Simmons | Phi-N | |
| 13A | Mickey Vernon | Was-A | |
| 13N | Roy Campanella | Bro-N | |
| 14A | Sammy White | Bos-A | |
| 14N | Jim Gilliam | Bro-N | |
| 15A | Gene Woodling | NY-A | |
| 15N | Pee Wee Reese | Bro-N | |
| 16A | Whitey Ford | NY-A | |
| 16N | Duke Snider | Bro-N | |
| 17A | Phil Rizzuto | NY-A | |
| 17N | Rip Repulski | StL-N | |
| 18A | Bob Porterfield | Was-A | |
| 18N | Robin Roberts | Phi-N | |
| 19A | Chico Carrasquel | Chi-A | |
| 19N | Enos Slaughter | StL-N | Card 19N Gus Bell also exists |
| 19N | Gus Bell | Cin-N | Card 19N Enos Slaughter also exists |
| 20A | Yogi Berra | NY-A | |
| 20N | Johnny Logan | Mil-N | |
| 21A | Bob Lemon | Cle-A | |
| 21N | Johnny Antonelli | NY-N | |
| 22A | Ferris Fain | Chi-A | |
| 22N | Gil Hodges | Bro-N | |
| 23A | Hank Bauer | NY-A | |
| 23N | Eddie Mathews | Mil-N | |
| 24A | Jim Delsing | Det-A | |
| 24N | Lew Burdette | Mil-N | |
| 25A | Gil McDougald | NY-A | |
| 25N | Willie Mays | NY-N |