Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Joe Tinker	Chi-N
2	Harry Heilmann	Det-A
3	Jack Chesbro	NY-A
4	Christy Mathewson	NY-N
5	Herb Pennock	NY-A
6	Cy Young	Cle-A	Cleveland, Boston
7	Ed Walsh	Chi-A
8	Nap Lajoie	Cle-A
9	Eddie Plank	Phi-A
10	Honus Wagner	Pit-N
11	Chief Bender	Phi-A
12	Walter Johnson	Was-A
13	Mordecai Brown	Chi-N
14	Rabbit Maranville	Bos-N
15	Lou Gehrig	NY-A
16	Ban Johnson	AL
17	Babe Ruth	NY-A
18	Connie Mack	Phi-A
19	Hank Greenberg	Det-A
20	John McGraw	NY-N
21	Johnny Evers	Chi-N
22	Al Simmons	Phi-A
23	Jimmy Collins	Bos-A
24	Tris Speaker	Cle-A	Boston, Cleveland
25	Frank Chance	Chi-N
26	Fred Clarke	Pit-N
27	Wilbert Robinson	Bro-N
28	Dazzy Vance	Bro-N
29	Pete Alexander	Phi-N
30	Kenesaw Landis	Commisioner
31	Willie Keeler	NY-A	Baltimore, Brooklyn, New York
32	Rogers Hornsby	StL-N
33	Hugh Duffy	Bos-N
34	Mickey Cochrane	Phi-A
35	Ty Cobb	Det-A
36	Mel Ott	NY-N
37	Clark Griffith	Chi-N
38	Ted Lyons	Chi-A
39	Cap Anson	Chi-N
40	Bill Dickey	NY-A
41	Eddie Collins	Phi-A