| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| 1 | Joe DiMaggio | NY-A | |
| 2 | Yogi Berra | NY-A | |
| 3 | Warren Spahn | Bos-N | Braves |
| 4 | Robin Roberts | Phi-N | |
| 5 | Ernie Banks | Chi-N | |
| 6 | Willie Mays | NY-N | Giants |
| 7 | Mickey Mantle | NY-A | |
| 8 | Roy Campanella | Bro-N | |
| 9 | Stan Musial | StL-N | |
| 10 | Ted Williams | Bos-A | |
| 11 | Ed Bailey | Cin-N | |
| 12 | Ted Kluszewski | Cin-N | |
| 13 | Ralph Kiner | Cle-A | Pictured with Cle-A, listed with Pit-N |
| 13 | Ralph Kiner | Pit-N | Pictured with Cle-A, listed with Pit-N |
| 14 | Dick Littlefield | Pit-N | |
| 15 | Nellie Fox | Chi-A | |
| 16 | Billy Pierce | Chi-A | |
| 17 | Richie Ashburn | Phi-N | |
| 18 | Del Ennis | Phi-N | |
| 19 | Bob Lemon | Cle-A | |
| 20 | Early Wynn | Cle-A | |
| 21 | Joe Collins | NY-A | |
| 22 | Hank Bauer | NY-A | |
| 23 | Roberto Clemente | Pit-N | |
| 24 | Frank Thomas | Pit-N | |
| 25 | Alvin Dark | NY-N | Giants |
| 26 | Whitey Lockman | NY-N | Giants |
| 27 | Larry Doby | Cle-A | |
| 28 | Bob Feller | Cle-A | |
| 29 | Willie Jones | Phi-N | |
| 30 | Granny Hamner | Phi-N | |
| 31 | Clem Labine | Bro-N | |
| 32 | Ralph Branca | Bro-N | |
| 33 | Jack Harshman | Chi-A | |
| 34 | Dick Donovan | Chi-A | |
| 35 | Tommy Henrich | NY-A | |
| 36 | Jerry Coleman | NY-A | |
| 37 | Billy Hoeft | Det-A | |
| 38 | Johnny Groth | Det-A | |
| 39 | Harvey Haddix | StL-N | |
| 40 | Gerry Staley | StL-N | |
| 41 | Dale Long | Pit-N | |
| 42 | Vern Law | Pit-N | |
| 43 | Dodger Power | Bro-N | |
| 43 | Duke Snider | Bro-N | |
| 43 | Gil Hodges | Bro-N | |
| 43 | Roy Campanella | Bro-N | |
| 43 | Carl Furillo | Bro-N | |
| 44 | Sam Jethroe | Bos-N | |
| 45 | Vic Wertz | Cle-A | Sample version exists with Detroit uniform, Cleveland on back, no number |
| 46 | Wes Westrum | NY-N | Giants |
| 47 | Dee Fondy | Chi-N | |
| 48 | Gene Baker | Chi-N | |
| 49 | Sandy Koufax | Bro-N | |
| 50 | Billy Loes | Bro-N | |
| 51 | Chuck Diering | NY-N | Giants |
| 52 | Joe Ginsberg | Det-A | |
| 53 | Jim Konstanty | Phi-N | |
| 54 | Curt Simmons | Phi-N | |
| 55 | Alex Kellner | KC-A | Incorrectly listed as Phi-N; never played for Phillies |
| 56 | Chuck Dressen | Bro-N | |
| 57 | Frank Sullivan | Bos-A | |
| 58 | Mel Parnell | Bos-A | |
| 59 | Bobby Hofman | NY-N | |
| 60 | Bill Connelly | NY-N | |
| 61 | Corky Valentine | Cin-N | |
| 62 | Johnny Klippstein | Cin-N | |
| 63 | Chuck Tanner | Chi-N | |
| 64 | Dick Drott | Chi-N | |
| 65 | Dean Stone | Was-A | |
| 66 | Jim Busby | Was-A | |
| 67 | Sid Gordon | Bos-N | |
| 68 | Del Crandall | Bos-N | |
| 69 | Walker Cooper | Chi-N | |
| 70 | Hank Sauer | Chi-N | |
| 71 | Gil Hodges | Bro-N | |
| 72 | Duke Snider | Bro-N | |
| 73 | Sherm Lollar | Chi-A | |
| 74 | Chico Carrasquel | Chi-A | |
| 75 | Gus Triandos | Bal-A | |
| 76 | Bob Harrison | Bal-A | |
| 77 | Eddie Waitkus | Phi-N | |
| 78 | Ken Heintzelman | Phi-N | |
| 79 | Harry Simpson | Cle-A | |
| 80 | Luke Easter | Cle-A | |
| 81 | Ed Dick | NY-A | |
| 82 | Jim DePalo | NY-A | |
| 83 | Billy Cox | Bro-N | |
| 84 | Pee Wee Reese | Bro-N | |
| 85 | Virgil Trucks | Chi-A | |
| 86 | George Kell | Chi-A | |
| 87 | Mickey Vernon | Was-A | |
| 88 | Eddie Yost | Was-A | |
| 89 | Gus Bell | Cin-N | |
| 90 | Wally Post | Cin-N | |
| 91 | Ed Lopat | NY-A | |
| 92 | Dick Wakefield | NY-A | |
| 93 | Solly Hemus | StL-N | |
| 94 | Red Schoendienst | StL-N | |
| 95 | Sammy White | Bos-A | |
| 96 | Billy Goodman | Bos-A | |
| 97 | Jim Hearn | NY-N | |
| 98 | Ruben Gomez | NY-N | |
| 99 | Marty Marion | StL-N | |
| 100 | Bill Virdon | Pit-N | |
| 101 | Chuck Stobbs | Bos-A | Pictured with Bos-A, listed with Was-A |
| 101 | Chuck Stobbs | Was-A | Pictured with Bos-A, listed with Was-A |
| 102 | Ron Samford | Was-A | |
| 103 | Bill Tuttle | Det-A | |
| 104 | Harvey Kuenn | Det-A | |
| 105 | Joe Cunningham | StL-N | |
| 106 | Bill Sarni | StL-N | |
| 107 | Jack Kramer | NY-N | |
| 108 | Eddie Stanky | NY-N | |
| 109 | Carmen Mauro | Bro-N | |
| 110 | Wayne Belardi | Bro-N | |
| 111 | Preston Ward | Pit-N | |
| 112 | Jack Shepard | Pit-N | |
| 113 | Buddy Kerr | Bos-N | |
| 114 | Vern Bickford | Bos-N | |
| 115 | Ellis Kinder | Bos-A | |
| 116 | Walt Dropo | Bos-A | |
| 117 | Duke Maas | NY-A | |
| 118 | Billy Hunter | NY-A | |
| 119 | Ewell Blackwell | Cin-N | |
| 120 | Hersh Freeman | Cin-N | |
| 121 | Fred Martin | StL-N | |
| 122 | Erv Dusak | StL-N | Incorrectly listed as Bro-N; never played for Brooklyn |
| 123 | Roy Hartsfield | Bos-N | |
| 124 | Willard Marshall | Bos-N | |
| 125 | Jack Sanford | Phi-N | |
| 126 | Herm Wehmeier | Phi-N | Pictured with Phi-N, listed with Cin-N |
| 126 | Herm Wehmeier | Cin-N | Pictured with Phi-N, listed with Cin-N |
| 127 | Hal Smith | KC-A | A's |
| 128 | Jim Finigan | KC-A | A's |
| 129 | Bob Hale | Bal-A | |
| 130 | Jim Wilson | Bal-A | |
| 131 | Bill Wight | Bos-A | |
| 132 | Mike Fornieles | Bos-A | |
| 133 | Steve Gromek | Cle-A | |
| 134 | Herb Score | Cle-A | |
| 135 | Ryne Duren | NY-A | |
| 136 | Bob Turley | NY-A | |
| 137 | Wally Moon | StL-N | |
| 138 | Fred Hutchinson | Det-A | Pictured with Det-A, listed with StL-N; sample version exists with Cards uniform |
| 138 | Fred Hutchinson | StL-N | Pictured with Det-A, listed with StL-N; sample version exists with Cards uniform |
| 139 | Jim Hegan | Cle-A | |
| 140 | Dale Mitchell | Cle-A | |
| 141 | Walt Moryn | Chi-N | |
| 142 | Cal Neeman | Chi-N | |
| 143 | Billy Martin | NY-A | |
| 144 | Phil Rizzuto | NY-A | |
| 145 | Preacher Roe | Bro-N | |
| 146 | Carl Erskine | Bro-N | |
| 147 | Vic Power | KC-A | |
| 148 | Elmer Valo | KC-A | |
| 149 | Don Mueller | NY-N | |
| 150 | Hank Thompson | NY-N | |
| 151 | Stan Lopata | Phi-N | |
| 152 | Dick Sisler | Phi-N | |
| 153 | Willard Schmidt | Cin-N | |
| 154 | Roy McMillan | Cin-N | |
| 155 | Gil McDougald | NY-A | |
| 156 | Gene Woodling | NY-A | |
| 157 | Eddie Mathews | Mil-N | Braves |
| 158 | Johnny Logan | Mil-N | Braves |
| 159 | Dan Bankhead | Bro-N | |
| 160 | Joe Black | Bro-N | |
| 161 | Roger Maris | KC-A | |
| 162 | Bob Cerv | KC-A | |
| 163 | Paul Minner | Chi-N | |
| 164 | Bob Rush | Chi-N | |
| 165 | Gene Hermanski | Chi-N | |
| 166 | Harry Brecheen | StL-N | |
| 167 | Davey Williams | NY-N | |
| 168 | Monte Irvin | NY-N | |
| 169 | Clint Courtney | Chi-A | |
| 170 | Sandy Consuegra | Chi-A | |
| 171 | Bobby Shantz | Phi-A | Pictured with Phi-A, listed with KC-A |
| 171 | Bobby Shantz | KC-A | Pictured with Phi-A, listed with KC-A |
| 172 | Harry Byrd | Phi-A | |
| 173 | Marv Throneberry | NY-A | |
| 174 | Woodie Held | NY-A | |
| 175 | Al Rosen | Cle-A | |
| 176 | Rance Pless | NY-N | |
| 177 | Steve Bilko | StL-N | |
| 178 | Joe Presko | StL-N | |
| 179 | Ray Boone | Cle-A | |
| 180 | Jim Lemon | Was-A | Pictured with Was-A; listed with Cle-A |
| 180 | Jim Lemon | Cle-A | Pictured with Was-A; listed with Cle-A |
| 181 | Andy Pafko | Bro-N | |
| 182 | Don Newcombe | Bro-N | |
| 183 | Frank Lary | Det-A | Incorrectly listed as StL-N; never played with Cardinals |
| 184 | Al Kaline | Det-A | |
| 185 | Allie Reynolds | NY-A | |
| 186 | Vic Raschi | NY-A | |
| 187 | Dodger Braintrust | Bro-N | |
| 187 | Walter Alston | Bro-N | |
| 187 | Joe Becker | Bro-N | |
| 187 | Jake Pitler | Bro-N | |
| 187 | Billy Herman | Bro-N | |
| 188 | Jim Piersall | Bos-A | |
| 189 | George Wilson | NY-N | |
| 190 | Dusty Rhodes | NY-N | |
| 191 | Duane Pillette | Bal-A | |
| 192 | Dave Philley | Bal-A | |
| 193 | Bobby Morgan | Bro-N | |
| 194 | Russ Meyer | Bro-N | |
| 195 | Hector Lopez | KC-A | |
| 196 | Arnie Portocarrero | KC-A | |
| 197 | Joe Page | NY-A | |
| 198 | Tommy Byrne | NY-A | |
| 199 | Ramon Monzant | SF-N | Pictured with SF-N, listed with NY-N |
| 200 | Windy McCall | NY-N | |
| 201 | Leo Durocher | NY-N | |
| 202 | Bobby Thomson | NY-N | |
| 203 | Jack Banta | Bro-N | |
| 204 | Joe Pignatano | LA-N | Pictured with LA-N, listed with Bro-N |
| 205 | Carlos Paula | Was-A | |
| 206 | Roy Sievers | Was-A | |
| 207 | Mickey McDermott | Bos-A | |
| 208 | Ray Scarborough | Bos-A | |
| 209 | Bill Miller | NY-A | |
| 210 | Bill Skowron | NY-A | |
| 211 | Bob Nieman | Bal-A | |
| 212 | Al Pilarcik | Bal-A | |
| 213 | Jerry Priddy | Det-A | |
| 214 | Frank House | Det-A | |
| 215 | Don Mossi | Cle-A | |
| 216 | Rocky Colavito | Cle-A | |
| 217 | Brooks Lawrence | StL-N | |
| 218 | Ted Wilks | StL-N | |
| 219 | Zach Monroe | NY-A | |
| 220 | Art Ditmar | NY-A | |
| 221 | Cal McLish | Cle-A | |
| 222 | Gene Bearden | Cle-A | |
| 223 | Norm Siebern | NY-A | |
| 224 | Bob Wiesler | NY-A | |
| 225 | Foster Castleman | NY-N | |
| 226 | Daryl Spencer | NY-N | |
| 227 | Dick Williams | Bro-N | |
| 228 | Don Zimmer | Bro-N | |
| 229 | Jackie Jensen | NY-A | |
| 230 | Billy Johnson | NY-A | |
| 231 | Dave Koslo | NY-N | |
| 232 | Al Corwin | NY-N | |
| 233 | Erv Palica | Bro-N | |
| 234 | Bob Milliken | Bro-N | |
| 235 | Ray Katt | NY-N | |
| 236 | Sam Calderone | NY-N | |
| 237 | Don Demeter | Bro-N | |
| 238 | Karl Spooner | Bro-N | Incorrectly listed with StL-N; never played with the Cardinals, but played in Cardinals system in 1958 |
| 239 | Preacher Roe | Bro-N | |
| 239 | Johnny Podres | Bro-N | |
| 240 | Enos Slaughter | NY-A | |
| 241 | Dick Kryhoski | Det-A | |
| 242 | Art Houtteman | Det-A | |
| 243 | Andy Carey | NY-A | |
| 244 | Tony Kubek | NY-A | |
| 245 | Mike McCormick | NY-N | |
| 246 | Bob Schmidt | SF-N | |
| 247 | Nellie King | Pit-N | |
| 248 | Bob Skinner | Pit-N | |
| 249 | Dick Bokelmann | StL-N | |
| 250 | Eddie Kazak | StL-N | Incorrectly listed with Det-A; never played with Tigers |
| 251 | Billy Klaus | Bos-A | |
| 252 | Norm Zauchin | Bos-A | |
| 253 | Art Schult | NY-A | |
| 254 | Bob Martyn | NY-A | |
| 255 | Larry Jansen | NY-N | |
| 256 | Sal Maglie | NY-N | |
| 257 | Bob Darnell | Bro-N | |
| 258 | Ken Lehman | Bro-N | |
| 259 | Jim Blackburn | Cin-N | |
| 260 | Bob Purkey | Cin-N | |
| 261 | Harry Walker | StL-N | |
| 262 | Joe Garagiola | StL-N | |
| 263 | Gus Zernial | Det-A | |
| 264 | Hoot Evers | Det-A | |
| 265 | Mark Freeman | NY-A | |
| 266 | Charlie Silvera | NY-A | |
| 267 | Johnny Podres | Bro-N | |
| 268 | Jim Hughes | Bro-N | |
| 269 | Al Worthington | NY-N | |
| 270 | Hoyt Wilhelm | NY-N | |
| 271 | Elston Howard | NY-A | |
| 272 | Don Larsen | NY-A | |
| 273 | Don Hoak | Bro-N | |
| 274 | Chico Fernandez | Bro-N | |
| 275 | Gail Harris | NY-N | |
| 276 | Valmy Thomas | NY-N | |
| 277 | George Shuba | Bro-N | |
| 278 | Rube Walker | Bro-N | |
| 279 | Willie Ramsdell | Chi-N | |
| 280 | Lindy McDaniel | StL-N | |
| 281 | Red Wilson | Bro-N | |
| 282 | Chuck Templeton | Bro-N | |
| 283 | Eddie Robinson | NY-A | |
| 284 | Bob Porterfield | Was-A | |
| 285 | Larry Miggins | StL-N | |
| 286 | Minnie Minoso | Chi-A | |
| 287 | Lou Boudreau | Bos-A | |
| 288 | Jim Davenport | SF-N | |
| 289 | Bob Miller | Phi-N | |
| 290 | Jim Gilliam | Bro-N | |
| 291 | Jackie Robinson | Bro-N | |
