| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| 1 | Mickey Mantle | NY-A | 1962 |
| 2 | Maury Wills | LA-N | 1962 |
| 3 | Elston Howard | NY-A | 1963 |
| 4 | Sandy Koufax | LA-N | 1963 |
| 5 | Brooks Robinson | Bal-A | 1964 |
| 6 | Ken Boyer | StL-N | 1964 |
| 7 | Zoilo Versalles | Min-A | 1965 |
| 8 | Willie Mays | SF-N | 1965 |
| 9 | Frank Robinson | Bal-A | 1966 |
| 10 | Roberto Clemente | Pit-N | 1966 |
| 11 | Carl Yastrzemski | Bos-A | 1967 |
| 12 | Orlando Cepeda | StL-N | 1967 |
| 13 | Denny McLain | Det-A | 1968 |
| 14 | Bob Gibson | StL-N | 1968 |
| 15 | Harmon Killebrew | Min-A | 1969 |
| 16 | Willie McCovey | SF-N | 1969 |
| 17 | Boog Powell | Bal-A | 1970 |
| 18 | Johnny Bench | Cin-N | 1970 |
| 19 | Vida Blue | Oak-A | 1971 |
| 20 | Joe Torre | StL-N | 1971 |
| 21 | Richie Allen | Chi-A | 1972 |
| 22 | Johnny Bench | Cin-N | 1972 |
| 23 | Reggie Jackson | Oak-A | 1973 |
| 24 | Pete Rose | Cin-N | 1973 |
| 25 | Jeff Burroughs | Tex-A | 1974 |
| 26 | Steve Garvey | LA-N | 1974 |
| 27 | Fred Lynn | Bos-A | 1975 |
| 28 | Joe Morgan | Cin-N | 1975 |
| 29 | Thurman Munson | NY-A | 1976 |
| 30 | Joe Morgan | Cin-N | 1976 |
| 31 | Rod Carew | Min-A | 1977 |
| 32 | George Foster | Cin-N | 1977 |
| 33 | Jim Rice | Bos-A | 1978 |
| 34 | Dave Parker | Pit-N | 1978 |
| 35 | Don Baylor | Cal-A | 1979 |
| 36 | Keith Hernandez | StL-N | 1979 |
| 37 | Willie Stargell | Pit-N | 1979 |
| 38 | George Brett | KC-A | 1980 |
| 39 | Mike Schmidt | Phi-N | 1980 |
| 40 | Rollie Fingers | Mil-A | 1981 |
| 41 | Mike Schmidt | Phi-N | 1981 |
| 42 | Don Drysdale | LA-N | 1968 Highlight |
| 43 | Hank Aaron | Atl-N | 1974 Highlight |
| 44 | Pete Rose | Phi-N | 1981 Highlight |