Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Ty Cobb	Det-A
2	Walter Johnson	Was-A
3	Christy Mathewson	NY-N
4	Josh Gibson	Homestead Grays
5	Honus Wagner	Pit-N
6	Jackie Robinson	Bro-N
7	Mickey Mantle	NY-A
8	Luke Appling	Chi-A
9	Ted Williams	Bos-A
10	Johnny Mize	StL-N
11	Satchel Paige	StL-A
12	Lou Boudreau	Cle-A
13	Jimmie Foxx	Phi-A
14	Duke Snider	Bro-N
15	Monte Irvin	NY-N
16	Hank Greenberg	Det-A
17	Roberto Clemente	Pit-N
18	Al Kaline	Det-A
19	Frank Robinson	Bal-A
20	Joe Cronin	Bos-A
21	Burleigh Grimes	Bro-N
22	Paul Waner	Pit-N
22	Lloyd Waner	Pit-N
23	Grover Alexander	Phi-N
24	Yogi Berra	NY-A
25	Cool Papa Bell	Pittsburgh Crawfords
26	Bill Dickey	NY-A
27	Cy Young	Cle-N	Cleveland Spiders
28	Charlie Gehringer	Det-A
29	Dizzy Dean	StL-N
30	Bob Lemon	Cle-A
31	Red Ruffing	NY-A
32	Stan Musial	StL-N
33	Carl Hubbell	NY-N
34	Hank Aaron	Mil-N
35	John McGraw	NY-N
36	Bob Feller	Cle-A
37	Casey Stengel	NY-A
38	Ralph Kiner	Pit-N
39	Roy Campanella	Bro-N
40	Mel Ott	NY-N
41	Robin Roberts	Phi-N
42	Early Wynn	Cle-A
43	Mickey Mantle	NY-A	Puzzle Card
44	Checklist Card