Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Hank Aaron	Atl-N
2	Grover Alexander	Phi-N
3	Ernie Banks	Chi-N
4	Yogi Berra	NY-A
5	Lou Brock	StL-N
6	Steve Carlton	Phi-N
7	Jack Chesbro	NY-A	Highlanders
8	Ty Cobb	Det-A
9	Sam Crawford	Det-A
10	Rollie Fingers	Mil-A
11	Whitey Ford	NY-A
12	John Frederick	Bro-N
13	Frankie Frisch	NY-N
14	Lou Gehrig	NY-A
15	Jim Gentile	Bal-A
16	Dwight Gooden	NY-N
17	Rickey Henderson	Oak-A
18	Rogers Hornsby	StL-N
19	Frank Howard	Was-A
20	Cliff Johnson	Tor-A
21	Walter Johnson	Was-A
22	Hub Leonard	Bos-A
23	Mickey Mantle	NY-A
24	Roger Maris	NY-A
25	Christy Mathewson	NY-N
26	Willie Mays	SF-N
27	Stan Musial	StL-N
28	Dan Quisenberry	KC-A
29	Frank Robinson	Cin-N
30	Pete Rose	Cin-N
31	Babe Ruth	NY-A
32	Nolan Ryan	Hou-N
33	George Sisler	StL-A
34	Tris Speaker	Cle-A
35	Ed Walsh	Chi-A
36	Lloyd Waner	Pit-N
37	Earl Webb	Bos-A
38	Ted Williams	Bos-A
39	Maury Wills	LA-N
40	Hack Wilson	Chi-N
41	Owen Wilson	Pit-N
42	Willie Wilson	KC-A
43	Rudy York	Det-A
44	Cy Young	Bos-A