
| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| 1 | Tommy Agee | Chi-A | 1966 |
| 2 | Luis Aparicio | Chi-A | 1956 |
| 3 | Frank Howard | LA-N | 1960 |
| 4 | Harvey Kuenn | Det-A | 1953 |
| 5 | Thurman Munson | NY-A | 1970 |
| 6 | Don Newcombe | Bro-N | 1949 |
| 7 | Tony Oliva | Min-A | 1964 |
| 8 | Jackie Robinson | Bro-N | 1947 |
| 9 | Herb Score | Cle-A | 1955 |
| 10 | Billy Williams | Chi-N | 1961 |