| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| 1 | Don Mattingly | NY-A | |
| 2 | Gary Carter | NY-N | |
| 3 | Tony Fernandez | Tor-A | |
| 4 | Steve Sax | LA-N | |
| 5 | Kirby Puckett | Min-A | |
| 6 | Mike Schmidt | Phi-N | |
| 7 | Mike Easler | NY-A | |
| 8 | Todd Worrell | StL-N | |
| 9 | George Bell | Tor-A | |
| 10 | Fernando Valenzuela | LA-N | |
| 11 | Roger Clemens | Bos-A | |
| 12 | Tim Raines | Mon-N |